Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Billions of Nile tilapia ( Oreochromis niloticus ) and African sharptooth catfish ( Clarias gariepinus ) are slaughtered annually, often without stunning. This study evaluated a prototype in-water electrical stunning system under semi-commercial farm conditions, separating the immediate induction of insensibility from its maintenance. Fish received short electrical exposures to assess induction of insensibility and longer exposures, with or without exsanguination and ice-slurry immersion, to assess recovery during a 10-min period. Sensibility was assessed using electroencephalography (EEG), including analyses of epileptic-like seizure activity and visually evoked responses (VERs). In tilapia, a 1-s head-to-tail exposure at 9.99 V cm −1 induced epileptic-like seizures, demonstrating that rapid disruption of brain function was achievable under this condition ( n = 4). In catfish, no clear epileptic-like seizures were detected in the EEG ( n = 7), and rapid induction was therefore not demonstrated. Prolonged stunning alone did not maintain insensibility in either species ( n = 8–10 per treatment). Following high-power, long-duration stunning combined with exsanguination and ice-slurry immersion (tilapia: 13.61 V rms cm −1 , 30 s; catfish: 17.41 V rms cm −1 , 40 s), recovery of VERs was not observed in catfish during the 10-min period, whereas transient recovery occurred in tilapia. Electrical stunning also accelerated rigor mortis development and lowered muscle pH compared with percussively stunned controls, demonstrating effects on post-mortem muscle physiology with potential implications for processing and product quality. Thus, with the prototype and settings evaluated, the tested protocols were not sufficiently reliable as standalone stunning methods. The data further support evaluating induction and maintenance as distinct requirements and show that optimisation must be species- and system-specific.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Sundell et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: