Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Background This study aimed to compare the accuracy and precision of CT-based planned central glenoid guide-pin placement among fluoroscopy-guided freehand insertion, CT-based patient-specific instrumentation (PSI), and CT-based navigation in a cadaveric reverse total shoulder arthroplasty (rTSA) model. Methods Six cadaveric shoulders were used. Three surgeons performed all three techniques in each shoulder (18 insertions per technique) under a shared preoperative plan. The sequence was fixed: fluoroscopy-guided freehand insertion, PSI, then navigation. After each insertion, guide-pin angle and entry-point position were measured by an independent assessor using the same navigation platform; recorded measurement values were not disclosed to the operating surgeon. Before the next insertion, the previous pin track was filled and visually/tactilely masked. Accuracy was assessed as deviation from the plan, and precision as the dispersion of deviations and the frequency of threshold-defined outliers. Overall successful placement was defined as angular deviations within ±5° in both inclination and retroversion and an entry-point offset magnitude ≤2.0 mm. Overall outlier status was defined as >10° deviation in either angular axis and/or an entry-point offset magnitude >4.0 mm. Results Resultant angular deviation was 6.8° (SD 4.2) for fluoroscopy, 5.7° (SD 4.6) for PSI, and 2.3° (SD 1.5) for navigation (p = 0.002). Entry-point offset magnitude was 3.2 mm (SD 1.3), 2.2 mm (SD 1.2), and 1.3 mm (SD 0.5), respectively (p < 0.001). Navigation showed smaller angular and positional deviations than both fluoroscopy and PSI. PSI improved entry-point offset magnitude versus fluoroscopy (p = 0.021) but not resultant angular deviation (p = 0.384). Overall successful placement occurred in 4/18 fluoroscopy insertions, 7/18 PSI insertions, and 17/18 navigation insertions (p < 0.001). Overall outliers occurred in 7/18, 4/18, and 0/18 insertions, respectively (p = 0.030). Conclusion In this fixed-sequence cadaveric rTSA model, navigation showed the smallest angular and entry-point deviations relative to the preoperative plan, and no threshold-defined outliers were observed. PSI improved entry-point accuracy compared with fluoroscopy-assisted freehand insertion but did not significantly improve angular accuracy. These findings characterize plan-to-pin execution at the guide-pin stage and require confirmation in studies evaluating final implant position and clinical outcomes.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Kiyomatsu et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: