Key result
Among 295 ATVB preclinical articles from 2016-2017, in vivo sex reporting increased from 79% to 92%, though only 11% in 2016 and 21% in 2017 studied both sexes.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
While overall reporting of animal sex in ATVB preclinical studies is high (79%-92%), inclusion of both sexes in vivo (11%-21%) and reporting of sex in primary cell cultures (27%-28%) remain low, prompting stricter editorial enforcement.
ATVB publishes research work that advances scientific fields in a rigorous and reproducible manner. We have implemented multiple approaches to follow the National Institutes of Health guidelines for rigor and reproducibility. In 2013, ATVB developed a checklist in the peer review process to facilitate comments on multiple technical requirements, including the sex of animals used in preclinical studies. We have also emphasized the National Institutes of Health guidelines that encourage researchers to study both sexes in preclinical animal models. These include publishing a review entitled “Sex Differences in the Development of Cardiovascular Diseases” and an ATVB Council statement to encourage authors to consider sex differences in designing and reporting experimental arterial pathology studies that detail the mode by which ATVB complies with the National Institutes of Health guidelines. The journal appointed a technical review editor, Dr Hong Lu, who assumed the role in September 2017 to assess the many elements required for adherence to the National Institutes of Health guidelines. These include issues such as the rigor of statistical analyses and animal background strain, age, and sex. The designation of sex of origin in studies of primary cells derived from cell culture is not as common as it is in animal studies. This is probably because of the unproven assumption that the lack of the hormonal environment in cell culture eliminates the need for designation of sex. However, because the differences of X and Y sex chromosomes and possibly sex-related differences in genomic imprinting are preserved in cultured cells, these cells could theoretically retain the ability to respond in a sex-dependent manner. Therefore, we also encourage and will monitor the reporting of sex in primary cell isolation and culture.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Lu et al. (2018) conducted an editorial in Preclinical cardiovascular research reporting of sex and sex differences (n=295). ATVB editorial policy and technical review on sex reporting vs. 2016 vs 2017 publication years was evaluated on Proportion of preclinical articles reporting sex information and studying both sexes in vivo and in primary cell cultures. Among 295 ATVB preclinical articles from 2016-2017, in vivo sex reporting increased from 79% to 92%, though only 11% in 2016 and 21% in 2017 studied both sexes.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: