Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Gut microbiota can provide substantial benefits to their hosts, but maintaining microbial communities may also impose physiological costs. How these costs and benefits emerge from interactions among microbial species remains poorly understood. Using a gnotobiotic honey bee system, we here systematically examined the effects of all 32 possible combinations of the five core gut bacterial species on host survival. Across all treatments, colonization by core microbiota generally reduced host lifespan relative to microbiota-depleted controls under controlled laboratory conditions, revealing that microbial colonization imposes a previously underappreciated baseline cost on the host. This negative effect was observed even in simple communities and became more pronounced with increasing community complexity. Accelerated failure time models showed that both individual species and higher-order interactions significantly influenced lifespan. Notably, interaction terms followed an alternating pattern: two- and four-species combinations exhibited positive effects, whereas three- and five-species combinations had negative effects. This qualitative trend was independently recapitulated in an external dataset from fruit flies, suggesting generality across host-microbe systems. Mathematical modeling suggested that competitive interactions among microbes generate the alternating odd-even pattern by reducing species abundances: density-dependent weakening of individual negative effects produces positive pairwise effects. Together, our results demonstrate that the effects of commensal gut bacteria on host survival depend strongly on microbial community context and highlight microbial competition as a potential mechanism underlying higher-order effects in host–microbiome systems.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Sato et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: