Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Background: Converting skinfold thicknesses into body fat percentage (%BF) assumes that subcutaneous adipose tissue (SAT) represents a fixed fraction of total fat, an assumption untested at extreme leanness. This study assessed whether skinfold–dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry (DXA) disagreement is random or structured by regional SAT. Methods: Thirty-five elite (Tier 4) female trail runners underwent anthropometry (Withers equation) and DXA in one session. Agreement was evaluated via Bland–Altman analysis and Lin’s concordance correlation coefficient (CCC). The inter-method difference (%BF_GAP = %BF_WITHERS − %BF_DXA) was regressed on android SAT, adjusted for total adiposity, and benchmarked against DXA-derived negative controls. Results: The methods correlated closely (r = 0.866) but showed poor concordance (CCC = 0.311). Skinfold estimates were systematically lower than DXA by 5.50 percentage points (pp; 95% limits of agreement −8.75 to −2.25 pp), with a proportional bias that widened with adiposity. Android SAT was associated with %BF_GAP (R2 = 0.489). Residualized on total fat mass, SAT retained an independent association (ΔR2 = 0.106), which no negative control showed. Propagated skinfold imprecision explained ~1.3% of the difference variance. Conclusions: The methods were not interchangeable. Their disagreement was systematic and associated with android SAT, but the design cannot show which method is closer to true body fat. In comparable athletes, converted skinfold %BF should not be reported alone or compared against DXA reference data; raw skinfold sums are preferable, as a variable to be observed rather than a target to be reduced.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Piñol-Granadino et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: