Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Background Healthcare priority setting under structural scarcity involves more than distributing limited resources. Institutional arrangements also shape who can access care, remain within treatment pathways, and benefit from available interventions. This paper develops Structural Moral Ecology (SME) as a normative framework for evaluating these conditions and their implications for distributive justice. Methods The paper employs conceptual and normative analysis, bringing Ecological Adverse Selection Theory into conversation with African relational ethics, ecostructural approaches to health ethics, and established theories of distributive and procedural justice. It distinguishes structural scarcity, understood as enduring conditions constraining the provision and use of care, from structural sorting, the mechanisms through which institutional arrangements distribute opportunities and burdens. The framework is applied to a constructed radiotherapy prioritisation case. Results The analysis establishes a distinction between justifying an immediate allocation decision and justifying the institutional conditions under which that decision becomes necessary. Although established allocation frameworks can address structural injustice, their application to particular decisions may leave institutional responsibilities insufficiently examined. Structural disadvantage may warrant accommodation, monitoring, escalation, or institutional remedy without automatically justifying a change in immediate allocation priority. The framework identifies three distinct normative judgements: duty attribution, duty specification, and duty prioritisation. It also develops an institutional capacity obligation connecting defensible decisions under existing constraints with continuing responsibility for fairer allocation conditions. Conclusions Structural Moral Ecology extends ethical assessment beyond the immediate distribution of scarce resources to the institutional responsibilities that persist after an allocation decision. By connecting allocation justice with continuing institutional accountability, it offers a framework for evaluating both the defensibility of present decisions and the conditions shaping access to care over time. Clinical Trial Registration Not applicable
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
George Rugare Chingarande (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: