Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Purpose This paper aims to examine to what extent published studies using de Waal’s high-performance organization (HPO) framework provide evidence consistent with a causal relationship between applying that framework and subsequent organizational performance improvement. Design/methodology/approach A structured evidence synthesis of 62 studies using de Waal’s HPO Framework was conducted. Each study was coded for temporal ordering (T), explicit performance outcomes (P) and reduction of alternative explanations (A) and was then assigned to one of five causal-evidence categories. Findings The published literature using de Waal’s HPO Framework provides clear but uneven indications of a causal relationship between HPO implementation and subsequent organizational performance improvement. The strongest longitudinal studies combine time-ordered intervention and outcome patterns with credible reduction of rival explanations, thereby supporting a contributory causal interpretation, although not definitive causal proof. The evidence base is heavily concentrated in studies authored or coauthored by the framework’s developer. In a sensitivity analysis excluding those studies, no high, high-medium or medium studies remain, indicating that independent causal evidence for the framework is currently limited. The absence of academically published overall negative cases should therefore be interpreted cautiously and not as proof that failed HPO transformations do not occur. Originality/value The article contributes a transparent, operationalized approach for assessing causal-evidence strength in the HPO case literature, clarifying what can (and cannot) be claimed about causality based on currently published evidence.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
André A. de Waal (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: