Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Standard nanoindentation analysis suppresses the time-dependent response of a tested material, discarding the property that governs how a heritage paint film survives climatic loading: its viscoplastic dissipation potential. We recover it, together with the elastic modulus, from a single displacement-controlled relaxation indent by Bayesian inverse identification through a Gaussian-process surrogate of a finite-element contact model. The central difficulty is that the constitutive law is adequate during relaxation but structurally violated during loading, where the particulate film deforms by granular compaction. Overweighting the loading forces the optimiser to absorb this model-form discrepancy into the constitutive parameters, leaving a deceptively good global fit. We expose this failure mode through a three-way audit of weighting schemes: expert-encoded physics, Fisher-information optimality, and a data-driven Empirical Bayes filter. Information-optimal weighting under model-form error produces the most biased parameters with an equally tight posterior, an effect we term Constitutive Overfitting. A polycarbonate control, for which the model is uniformly adequate, confirms that the three schemes converge, establishing the audit as a diagnostic of model inadequacy rather than a pipeline artefact. This work has two outcomes. The first is the complete viscoplastic dissipation potential of a heritage paint film, the rate-dependent descriptor that fracture and digital-twin models require, from a single high-information indent. The second is the audit: an unaudited inversion would report a tight posterior on a biased modulus, whereas the three-way comparison separates reliable parameters from artefacts wherever constitutive fidelity varies within a single experiment. Population-level variability is deferred to a forthcoming multi-indent study.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Riparbelli et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: