Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Theoretical models on intraguild predation (predation among organisms within the same trophic level, intraguild predation) assume a spatially heterogeneous primary productivity. Hence, resource-rich patches could attract both predators and prey, yet prey may suffer higher predation rates. This theoretical framework can be extended to antagonistic, size‑asymmetric interactions among herbivores in which negative effects arise not only from predation but also from other non‑trophic mechanisms. We analyzed antagonistic interactions driven by primary productivity among oak-defoliating Lepidoptera and livestock in Iberian oak savannas. Caterpillars defoliate oak canopies, but exclusion experiments have shown that free-range livestock predate/trample soil-pupating Lepidoptera. We used fine-scale multispectral imagery to assess the Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI) of oak canopies and surrounding pasture. Then, we tracked the visits of GPS-collared sheep in each tree of the study site, where we sampled oak-defoliating Lepidoptera caterpillars. NDVI of canopies and pasture were spatially correlated, and sheep grazed more often at more productive patches. Negative top-down effects (increased predation/trampling) outweighed positive bottom-up ones (increased food availability) in soil-pupating Lepidoptera, whose abundance was lower in productive pastures due to higher sheep activity. In contrast, species pupating in leaves/branches were more abundant in those trees, benefiting from increased productivity while avoiding predation, as their pupae were inaccessible to sheep. Irrespective of the underlying mechanisms (direct predation and/or trampling), our results show that assessments of antagonistic interactions between large herbivores and insects must incorporate landscape‑level variation in productivity and the movement abilities of both guilds.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Gaytán et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: