Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This project seeks to complicate Asian American histories of exclusion by framing Asian diasporic identity and politics as shaped by transpacific processes of selective incorporation. Selective incorporation is a materialist feminist analytic that examines the dialectical processes of strategic assimilation and recognition of East Asian diasporas within global networks of exchange and value. I trace the trajectories of sojourners and capital—the foreign exchange student, the banknote, the Midway Atoll, the transracial author, the transpacific orphan, the adjunct lecturer, the student-terrorist-activist—across the nineteenth and twentieth centuries. Through processes of selective incorporation, subjects such as the foreign exchange student are temporarily exempt from exclusion. Paradoxically, exempt subjects are people granted access across borders, those who “get in” to universities, professions, and nations. Islands and their people’s complex polities are subject to “gunboat diplomacy,” with the land annexed by settler and imperial states and the people forced to assimilate. Exempt subjects are incorporated, however temporarily, into settler states like the US and Japan. In this sense, exemption is a form of subjection and enclosure, of bringing under control and setting apart for varied purposes. In particular, the foreign exchange student emerges as an exempt subject. Though settler systems attempt to shape her into a liberal subject, she is nevertheless haunted by the slave, coolie, and prostitute. As a non-citizen with temporary merit-based status, the foreign exchange student is both hyperproductive and non-reproductive. She embodies queer kinship and the abstract value of labor. She emerges from cultural evolutionary scientific discourse as a disciplinary category, mediating the borders between child and adult, beneficiary and worker, and free and unfree. Lastly, it reveals the centrality of modern education systems and the university in shaping Asian diasporic student politics and identity. I read Asian/American subject formation through Native feminist and critical race theories of possession, particularly in relation to whiteness, and offer selective incorporation to think through the global vectors of power that produce and entangle Asian peoples in global hierarchies of race. I demonstrate how speculative investors—settler governments, colonial administrators, missionaries, merchants, and colleges—sought to manage transpacific populations, and how Asian and Pacific peoples’ desires and politics shaped their participation in imperial, settler, and capitalist systems. In this context, Asian racialization, gender, and sexuality are revealed to be settler technologies used by multiple, overlapping colonial and capitalist projects, and critical frameworks in queer, crip, Third World, and Indigenous politics. As processes of selective incorporation intensify ongoing contradictions in the 20th and 21st centuries, this dissertation traces the increasing contestations over sovereignty and self-determination waged within institutions of knowledge from the Third World Student Strikes to the institutionalization of Ethnic Studies, the overturning of affirmative action, and the criminalization of student-led encampments against the genocide in Palestine on college campuses.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Michelle Ling (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: