Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Chemistry has long distinguished two kinds of optical activity that look alike but are not: natural optical activity, which entails a handed molecule or a chiral solid, and magnetic optical activity, which requires an external, time-reversal-breaking field. The difference is one of symmetry─of the field and of the matter─not of shape─a distinction easily conflated when chirality is read from a two-dimensional image of a field. We make it concrete on the nanometer–femtosecond (“nanofemto”) scale using the vectorial near field of a surface-plasmon-polariton vortex. The whole distinction lives in one complex quantity, the bilinear coprojection E·B*: its imaginary part is the optical chirality density (parity-odd, time-even) pseudoscalar that defines true chirality, while its real part is the magnetoelectric density (parity-odd, time-odd,PT -even) that marks false chirality. Nonlinear photoemission electron microscopy images the vortex field as a purely false-chiral, reactive Re[E·B*] focus at its core, where the true-chiral density vanishes. But reactive does not mean inert. We trace this to a common thread in the 1985 magnetic-rotation spectroscopy of singlet methylene, in which spin–orbit coupling rendered a dark, spin-forbidden channel observable. The two are time-reversal conjugates within a single magnetoelectric classification: methylene magnetic rotation realizes the time-even (true-chiral) member, governed by the pseudoscalar k·B, whereas the plasmonic vortex is the magnet-free, all-optical realization of its time-odd (false-chiral) partner, governed by E·B─the same symmetry handle read in opposite time-reversal parities, 40 years on.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Chen et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: