Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The accurate estimation of earthwork volume, which constitutes the primary cost driver in road planning and construction, is crucial for project budget management and environmental sustainability. This study conducts a comparative analysis of traditional versus modern estimation techniques along an existing road alignment in the Istanbul University-Cerrahpaşa Research Forest. High-resolution terrain data, acquired via Real-Time Kinematic Global Navigation Satellite System (RTK-GNSS) and Total Station integrated surveys, were used to test the Average End Area, Prismoidal, Simplified Applicable Lengths, and Pappus-based methods utilizing both field-measured and standard template cross-sections. In the context of computer-aided design (CAD) analyses, models incorporating varying cross-section intervals and sampling strategies were generated using AutoCAD Civil 3D, and the resulting volume estimates were subjected to statistical evaluation. Results indicated that calculations based on field-measured cross-sections resulted in a significant »fill deficit«, whereas the use of standard template cross-sections consistently led to a distinct »cut surplus«. Among traditional methods, the Prismoidal and Pappus-based methods produced the most precise results, whereas the widely used Average End Area Method overestimated earthwork volumes. In computer-aided approaches, automatic cross-section sampling based on road geometry and 5-meter fixed interval modeling yielded no statistically significant difference from the reference method – defined as the arithmetic mean of the Average End Area and Prismoidal results at 1 m cross-section intervals in Civil 3D – confirming their reliability. These findings highlight the importance of employing 5-meter interval modeling in CAD environments for optimal alignment selection. Furthermore, the study advocates for the use of the Pappus-based method in traditional calculations due to its consideration of the horizontal curvature effect.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Topatan et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: