Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Few constructs in management research have proved as generative as organizational attention, and few have been left so largely unexamined at their core. This Point‐Counterpoint debate brings a dormant question into the open: what exactly is attention? The Point argues for an ontological reorientation of the Attention‐Based View from attention quantity to attention quality, reconceptualizing attention as a set of sociomaterial practices of attending that are crescive and differentiated rather than limited and homogeneous. One Counterpoint defends the ontological integrity of attention as scarce, selective, and situated, warning that a crescive ontology dissolves the very constraint from which attention derives its explanatory power. The other Counterpoint charts an expansive third way, tracing the contested assumptions to Herbert Simon's legacy and proposing to broaden the Attention‐Based View towards competition, thicker situations, and possible attentional abundance. In this introduction to the debate, we present the three positions and reflect on what their disagreement teaches us about ontological disputes in management theory more generally. We distil three tests – of phenomena, of explanation, and of genealogy – that scholars can apply when deciding whether a construct's ontology deserves revision, defence, or expansion.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Aversa et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: