Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The article analyzes the concept of resilient safety (Safety II) proposed by the Danish psychologist Erik Hollnagel, one of the leading specialists in the field of safety and reliability of sociotechnical systems. Despite the authority of this concept, the analysis shows that it has an almost exclusively technical and formalized orientation, which leads it beyond the subject matter of psychology and results in the loss of its psychological content. The approach under consideration focuses on a type of accident resulting from the coincidence of unlikely events, known as functional resonance, and on the FRAM method for identifying the conditions under which it occurs. The article describes the subject context of the problem, namely the technical and engineering-psychological approaches to the safety problem, which makes it possible to assess Hollnagel’s concept as a new attempt to describe the role of the human factor in sociotechnical systems through the projection of technical categories onto it, as was the case in the early 1960s. Thus, the opposition between reactive and proactive approaches is borrowed from risk management. The FRAM “what-if” method is analogous to the methods developed in reliability theory for constructing “success scenarios” and “accident scenarios,” such as HAZOP, HAZID, SIL, and others. The “aspects” of a function, namely input, time, output, resource, control, and precondition that structure risk identification under the FRAM method are functionally similar to the “guide words” used in HAZOP and similar methods. The search for conditions under which functional resonance may occur is semantically equivalent to identifying beyond-design-basis scenarios, as defined in reliability theory. In general, the FRAM method is aimed at detailing and correcting the formal and role-related aspects of work and at ensuring its maximum compliance with instructions. It does not address the issue of the motivational drivers of an employee’s actions, that is, their specifically psychological mechanisms.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
A 2026 study studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: