Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
We study a finite discrete identification problem: given a finite set X, a target ρ:X→ℝ, and a two-tier observation π=(q,r):X→ A× B, when does a detector D with D∘π=ρ exist, and if not, how is the obstruction quantified? We separate local fiber capacities μ_a, the global fiberwise mixing degree μ_fib, the coarse aggregate mixing degree τ(q), and the natural row count ν_r. Exact detection is equivalent to μ_fib=1; this equivalence is a standard identifiability/rough-set starting point, not a new result, and is used as a unified language. Row structure is formalized via a conflict graph; ν_r is a set-partition number, and the atomic row count reduces to bin packing in the no-conflict case, where the decision problem is NP-complete and admits no PTAS. The product counting chain τ(q)≤μ_fibν_r(π) is unconditional; saturation is characterized by perfect row representations. For μ_fib>1 the unrestricted disambiguation budget equals μ_fib; restricted budgets admit universal, entropy, and span lower bounds. The Three-Layer Bridge. The core contribution is a unified logical chain: (1) Local Discrete Core: combinatorial constraints on row-labeling (natural row count ν_r); (2) Topological Obstruction: non-abelian Čech cohomology on the separable row-label groupoid, instantiated as a groupoid-valued presheaf on the Čech nerve in the sense of Giraud–Moerdijk, yields an explicit obstruction class [c] whose vanishing is equivalent to the existence of a global section; (3) Macroscopic Resource Transition: the Bridge Theorem (Theorem[thm:bridge], proven under the uniform rate definition and the monodromy-preserving operation set) proves that the non-trivial topological obstruction (H⁰=∅) forbids positive uniform distillation rates (R_dist=0) while preserving dilution (R_dil>0). The distillation rate spectrum (Proposition[prop:rate-spectrum]) refines this: the distillable tensor powers are exactly those n for which Mon_∞ⁿ has a fixed point, and the per-copy rate on this subsequence is logμ_fib; the uniform rate is zero because the complement of this set is infinite. The zero-rate bound is carried by the monodromy obstruction, not by monotonicity of logμ_fib: logμ_fib is not a monotone under monodromy-preserving operations (Proposition[prop:mufib-not-monotone]). This connects local combinatorics to macroscopic resource asymmetry via global topology. A verified |I|=3 no-descent-data obstruction is given in the separable layer (Proposition[prop:no-descent]), and a polynomial-time path-consistency criterion is obtained by instantiating the known majority-polymorphism bounded-width theorem on a median-polymorphism subclass (Theorem[thm:median-path]); the contribution is the verification of condition (L) on the separable row-label constraint language, not the bounded-width theorem itself. Theorem[thm:i2-elimination] eliminates the |I|=2 case on connected nerves under the standing restriction hypothesis H-restrict; without H-restrict, Proposition[prop:i2-counterexample] gives a connected 4-cycle counterexample, so the verified |I|=3 obstruction is minimal in the separable layer under H-restrict. The resource part establishes an obstruction-based resource dichotomy for ℤ-ladders under the monodromy-preserving operation set (Theorem[thm:correspondence]): H⁰≠∅ iff full distillation at rate logμ_fib, and H⁰=∅ iff zero uniform distillation, with dilution at least logμ_fib. Proposition[prop:z-ladder-no-fourth] shows that on a ℤ-ladder the fourth-type obstruction does not occur independently of monodromy, so the dichotomy is exhaustive. It is realized by Model D.1 (Abelian monodromy), Model D.2 (non-Abelian finite-order monodromy), and Model D.3 (syndrome/coset ladder with unbounded label space). Boundary of claims. The finite core is proved unconditionally. The gluing and resource parts contain one verified obstruction and an obstruction-based resource dichotomy on ℤ-ladders under monodromy-preserving operations, realized by Abelian and non-Abelian finite-order monodromy models. The continuous-limit section is conditional on H4/H6. The noncommutative and Postnikov sections are an outlook. The effective-descent hypothesis (H-ED) and edge-slack positivity (H-ESP) are not verified in general. H-restrict is a working hypothesis for the elimination statements; without it, |I|=2 obstructions can occur (Proposition[prop:i2-counterexample]). Genuine fourth-type obstructions on complexes with nontrivial fundamental group are outside the scope of this paper.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Boomer Boris (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: