Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
A companion to Project Raphael Revisited (November 2026). Raphael Revisited showed that a loop of Janus transistors holds a single state, like the howl of a microphone held near its own loudspeaker. This paper adds time. It asks what a loop with a delay holds, what several loops hold together, and which harmonies such loops prefer. It takes up two ideas behind the first edition of Raphael: the fugue, and playing the Luoshu and the Hetu as melodies. (1) A note. In a microphone–loudspeaker loop the round-trip delay picks the pitch: the simulated howl matches the whole-period condition in 115 of 117 cases. (2) A melody. A loop of 1000 gates, whose forward connections arrive through a delay line, replays a stored melody. Given the Luoshu read row by row (4 9 2 3 5 7 8 1 6), it replays it without error, and it holds melodies of up to about 80 notes. Its beat is the delay. Opening the delay in mid-melody leaves a held state, the howl of Raphael Revisited. (3) A canon. Three voices entering one bar apart sing the Luoshu round, in which every chord is a column of the magic square summing to 15, in 4 of 5 networks. Random orders of 1–9 do about as well. Two voices are held reliably and three only sometimes. Notes that share harmonics blur. (4) Loops that lock. Self-sustained push–pull loops lock most widely at 1:3 and 1:5, and at even ratios only at second order. Of the five Hetu pairs only earth (5:10, an octave) locks, and almost no triad locks. (5) A harmony function. Phase reduction gives the locking range of two loops with no fitted constant: how loudly one loop sings a harmonic, times how readily the other hears it. Combined with the time locking takes, it selects a progression that locks at every step in 32 of 32 runs. A genetic search reaches 86%. The audio files are a translation: they make the loops' rhythms audible (the howl, the Luoshu melody and round, the delay cut, the Hetu, the evolved and the designed songs). Files: the paper in English, Traditional Chinese and Japanese (the English version governs); a primer in each language; code, sources and audio (code_and_sources.zip) reproducing every number and figure. The work is computational throughout; nothing is measured. Part of the Angelica Paper Series. Licence: text and figures CC BY 4.0; code Apache-2.0. Defensive publication: disclosed as prior art, free for anyone to use and not to be patented by others.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Tung Ning Liu (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: