Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The acquisition of an additional regulatory function may be constrained by the need to preserve an already established function during network extensions. This study examines that problem in a formal, model-specific setting using the mammalian cell-cycle regulatory network of Traynard et al. (2016). A DNA-damage checkpoint controlling the G1/S-associated cyclin E transition was added through five alternative logical signal architectures: a p53/p21 route, an ATR/CHK1/Cdc25A route, an ATM/CHK2/Cdc25A route, a dual fast route, and a combined architecture. The original cell-cycle phase sequence was used as the preservation criterion. An explicit-state asynchronous checker was used to enumerate reachable states and transitions, test checkpoint initiation and maintenance, and examine recovery after damage removal. In all five variants, the original phase sequence remained reachable when DNA damage was absent. Under persistent damage, no new cyclin E commitment transition was found from a state in which the checkpoint gate was already active and commitment had not yet occurred; nor was checkpoint-gate deactivation found while damage remained present. All examined active, uncommitted G1 checkpoint states had at least one recovery path after damage removal. However, checkpoint initiation was not guaranteed under unrestricted asynchronous updating: from the baseline initial state, a two-update path (E2F followed by CycE) could reach cyclin E activation before gate activation, and a timing-sensitivity analysis across 40 reachable baseline G1 states reproduced this bypass in one or two updates (depending on initial E2F status) in all four tested variants. These results distinguish preservation of an existing function from reliable initiation of an additional function. They establish a conditional property of the specified logical models, not an experimentally validated mechanism or a general limit on biological evolution.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Maurice Crutzen (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: