Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Ammonia and hydrogen sulfide are both weak hydrogen-bond (HB) donors, yet each molecule can donate and accept more than one HB, so their mixed networks branch readily. We use the molecular tailoring approach (MTA) at the MP2/aug-cc-pVTZ level to obtain the energy of every HB in 20 neutral (NH3)m(H2S)n clusters (m+ n = 3–7) and to split each energy into an isolated-dimer term and a cooperative term. The acceptor atom sets the energy scale: HBs accepted by nitrogen average 3.98 kcal mol−1 and those accepted by sulfur 2.28 kcal mol−1, and the S–H· · ·N bond is the strongest contact in almost every cluster (up to 7.49 kcal mol−1). Cooperativity is modest, 0.68 kcal mol−1 per HB or 21.8% of the total HB energy, and a sizeable minority of HBs are anticooperative. It is ordered mainly by local branching. With a branching index κ defined as the number of extra HBs donated by the donor molecule plus the number of extra HBs accepted by the acceptor molecule, the mean cooperative energy falls from 1.32 kcal mol−1 at κ = 0 to 0.28 kcal mol−1 at κ = 2 (Spearman ρ = −0.74). The S–H· · ·N bond, the strongest in isolation, is also the most sensitive to branching. At the cluster level, the cooperative share of the total HB energy falls from 33% in a monocyclic tetramer to 11% in a fused, branched heptamer. Branching thus provides a simple predictor of where a mixed HB network gains or loses non-additive stabilisation, and it indicates which contacts pairwise or uniformly scaled many-body models are likely to misdescribe.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Deepak Patkar (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: