Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
In Switzerland, displacement due to renovation or demolition of the existing housing stock is often framed in public and academic discourse as an individual hardship for affected tenants. This paper argues that displacement resulting from so-called “renovictions” constitutes a process of value appropriation, through which tenants and the public bear a substantial share of the costs of gains accruing to landowners and housing-asset holders. My argument builds on the case of renovictions in estates held by for-profit investors in Basel and Zurich, where, due to the specificities of Swiss tenant law, redevelopment often takes the form of lease terminations affecting entire tenant populations. Drawing on expert interviews with developers, real estate analysts, public authorities, social service providers, and tenants living in such estates, this paper examines three central mechanisms of value appropriation. First, it traces the extraction of reproduction-based housing and land values from both displaced and incoming tenants. Second, it examines how gains generated by publicly financed infrastructure and services are redistributed toward landowners and housing-asset holders, externalizing costs onto the public and undermining public investment in turn. These gains are sustained both by the taxes paid by the municipalities' working populations, who are, in both cases, disproportionately tenants, and by the low-paid labour through which urban improvements are (re-)produced. Third, the paper examines the exploitation of low-paid labour, including in the construction sector, whose work underpins the profits of the real estate industry. Renovictions thus expose a compounding extraction from working-class tenants, who contribute to the creation and financing of rising property values through their labour and taxes only to face higher rents and displacement as those same values are appropriated. This capturing of collectively produced value in the for-profit real estate market helps explain the deepening precarity of lower- and middle-income tenants in Switzerland, while renovictions further drive up asking rents and create pressing challenges for both tenants and public institutions.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Luisa Gehriger (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: