Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Cystoscopic instruments have predominantly been reusable, necessitating rigorous sterilization between uses. The rise in overdiagnosis of low-risk diseases has been linked to an unnecessary escalation in healthcare’s carbon footprint. Flexible cystoscopy, a cornerstone of urological diagnostics and therapeutics, has encountered challenges with reusable devices, including high purchase and repair costs, sterilization failures, exposure of health care professionals to toxic agents during sterilization procedures, and release of hospital waste into the environment. Our study aims to directly compare the costs and environmental impacts among various cystoscope types. Comprehensive evaluation of both the economic and environmental impacts of flexible cystoscopy procedures, facilitating direct comparisons between disposable and reusable cystoscope options. Disposable cystoscopes offered a more cost-effective option compared to reusable cystoscopes. While disposable cystoscopes ranged in price from $118 to $192 each, reusable cystoscopes, such as Olympus and Storz, amounted to $209.17 per use, including purchase and reprocessing costs. Reusable cystoscopes also incurred additional expenses for maintenance, repairs, and other associated costs. Furthermore, reusable cystoscopes require significant cleaning protocols involving personal protective equipment (PPE), multiple cleaning solutions, 60 L of water, and 121 min of processing time. Disposable cystoscopes not only are more cost efficient but also reduce water consumption – minimizing environmental impact. Further investigation into long-term economic and environmental implications of cystoscopes from manufacturing to disposing and reprocessing are needed.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Gressler et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: