Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Aggressive intrasexual competition is important for reproductive success in both sexes. Costs and benefits across reproductive stages will ultimately shape how this behaviour evolves, but these relationships are poorly understood for many female animals. Previous work with female northern house wrens has found that females who are more aggressive towards simulated female intruders have heavier offspring, an important predictor of nestling survival. However, the mechanism driving this relationship is unknown. To determine whether this effect occurs prior to egg laying, during incubation or after nestlings hatched, I swapped eggs between nests as they were laid and swapped nestlings to a third nest after they hatched. For nests where the prelaying, incubating and posthatching mother were all different, only the incubating female's aggression score was related to offspring size. Nestlings incubated by more aggressive females were larger at multiple points during development. Other nests were swapped only at the egg or the nestling stage to determine whether the effects of aggression are additive across stages. Results from these treatments suggest that this beneficial effect during incubation may be offset by neutral relationships or costs incurred during other stages or dampened by genetic or maternal effects established prior to laying. Further work is needed to determine whether the positive effect during incubation results from the behaviour of the female, her mate, or the characteristics of the territory. However, this contradicts patterns found between incubation behaviour and female aggression in some other well-studied species, highlighting the importance of species ecology, life history and mechanism to understanding how female–female aggressive competition evolves.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Cara A. Krieg (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: