Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Author's translation. English translation, by the author, of: DIETRICH, Pablo. A prova que o recurso não vê: a moldura fática, a omissão probatória e os limites do controle recursal nos tribunais superiores. Revista Nexus Interdisciplinar, Natal/RN, v. 1, n. 4, p. 163–196, Oct./Dec. 2026. DOI: 10.47538/RNI-2026.V1N4-11. The Portuguese text published by the journal is the version of reference; this translation is distributed under the CC BY 4.0 licence, with attribution to the original publication. Quotations from works consulted in Portuguese translation or in other languages are rendered into English by the author. The Brazilian special appeal works upon the reconstruction of facts established by the lower courts. When that reconstruction is itself the product of a violation of federal law, whether through the omission of relevant evidence, the closing of the evidentiary phase without required clarifications, or the unjustified rejection of expert evidence, the factual framework becomes at once the premise and the object of review. The question is how the Superior Court of Justice can legally review the incompleteness of that reconstruction without taking over the fact-finding role reserved to the lower courts. Drawing on legal scholarship and recent case law, the answer advanced is that the distinction between questions of fact and questions of law serves a legitimate institutional function but does not, by itself, explain either the cognition needed to identify the defect or the consequences of acknowledging it. Three dimensions of review are distinguished, namely the normative ground, the cognitive scope and the decisional scope, and a sufficiency test is proposed for substitutive decisions under article 1,034 of the Code of Civil Procedure, taking into account the scope of invalidation, the remaining premises, residual issues within the appeal, the burden of proof rule where insufficiency can be ascertained without reassessing the evidence, and the subjective reach of the judgment.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Pablo Dietrich (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: