Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Background Invisible triangular citations (ITCs)—a form of citation malpractice where authors of a follower document (C) derive content from a seminal work (A) through an unacknowledged intermediary (B)—pose a significant threat to knowledge provenance and academic integrity. This concealed practice is particularly hazardous in biomedical research, where distorted attribution can propagate misinterpreted concepts into clinical guidelines and therapeutic protocols. Current detection methods lack robust, content-based models to identify such obscured citation pathways. Objective The study aims to establish and empirically validate a dual-threshold framework for detecting ITCs in biomedical research by integrating textual similarity and bibliographic coupling strength and to characterize the positional and semantic patterns of these concealed citations. Methods Using Web of Science’s enriched cited references technology, we conducted a full-text citation analysis of 2948 source papers, 20,801 citing documents, and 37,542 citation sentences from the antibody-drug conjugate domain—a rapidly growing area of anticancer drug development, particularly in oncology. The framework combined textual similarity (cosine similarity) with bibliographic coupling strength (shared references). Across more than 2 million pairwise records, threshold selection and robustness were evaluated using Spearman rank correlation, sliding-window analysis, segmented linear regression, Bayesian information criterion improvement, enrichment factors, chi-square tests, Cramér V , threshold perturbation analysis, and expert review. Results Optimal detection thresholds were identified as cosine similarity ≥0.60 and coupling strength ≥10, beyond which citation behavior was more likely to show inconsistency between the formal citation and the substantive knowledge source. Among 2,085,004 effective pairwise records, 6165 ITC records were detected, accounting for 0.296% of all records. In a stratified random sample of 100 records independently and blindly reviewed by 3 experts, the expert confirmation rate was 85.00% (Wilson 95% CI 76.72%‐90.69%). Positional analysis showed that ITCs (n=12,274) were concentrated in the Introduction (n=6023, 49.1%) and Discussion (n=5833, 47.5%), whereas Results (n=255, 2.1%) and Methods (n=163, 1.3%) accounted for much smaller proportions. Citation position was statistically associated with both cosine similarity and bibliographic coupling strength, although the effect sizes were weak. Representative cases showed that ITCs may involve not only verbatim copying but also strategic rewriting through lexical substitution and syntactic restructuring. Conclusions This empirically validated dual-threshold framework provides a transferable model for ITC detection across biomedical disciplines. Cosine similarity and bibliographic coupling strength were significantly but weakly positively correlated (Spearman ρ=0.065, 95% CI 0.064‐0.066; P <.001), supporting a dual-threshold rather than a single-indicator model and suggesting that authors replicate reference structures while paraphrasing text. The vulnerability of the Introduction and Discussion sections highlights systemic weaknesses in knowledge transmission, with implications for clinical practice. This study pioneers the application of enriched cited references technology to safeguard attributional integrity and offers actionable governance strategies for research integrity.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Liu et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: