Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Purpose The decarbonization of the steel industry is an important contributor to reaching net-zero by 2050. Increased circularity is expected to aid in this transition. However, the constrained nature of scrap supply is often not accounted for, which could lead to unsustainable decision-making. A sliding scale framework could enable a more robust comparison between decarbonization measures. However, multiple frameworks have been developed, differing in their methodological approaches. Method A four step method was implemented to investigate three sliding scale frameworks. This consisted of a literature review, comparative analysis, life cycle assessment, and discussion and recommendation development. In the first two phases the method documents of sliding scale frameworks were studied and compared based on a selection of fundamental elements and modelling requirements. For each framework, nine life cycle assessment scenarios were developed, according to the different methodological requirements of the respective system. These scenarios depict varying stages of conventional and decarbonized production across major production pathways. Finally, the results of the comparative analysis and LCA have been discussed, to determine if sliding-scale frameworks offer a robust basis for comparison, and to provide recommendations for future harmonization efforts between different frameworks. Results The comparative analysis identified methodological differences for every investigated aspect. The influence of these differences on the LCA results is in the same order of magnitude as those brought on by technical decarbonization measures. While the sliding scale systems enable a comparison across different scenarios, different conclusions can be drawn depending on which system is chosen for the analysis. This is mainly due to how quantitative emission thresholds are derived, in addition to diverging definitions of low-emission steel production. Conclusions Harmonization is required for multiple elements of the sliding scale methodologies. Most importantly, the near-zero production definition should be refined to include additional quantitative criteria and a common definition of low-emission production is required. Furthermore, a uniform approach is required for determining quantitative emission thresholds. It is proposed that both near-zero and low-emission steel definitions be based on a reference installation threshold representing conventional production processes.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Krekel et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: