Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
An activity may give a person purpose, identity and relief, yet gradually become something they cannot live without. This tension brings Mihalits’s (2025) multidimensional account of extreme psychological experiences into conversation with research on behavioural addictions, where intense engagement is too easily interpreted through diagnostic criteria borrowed from substance use. His framework offers a way to describe intensity, control and psychological impact without prejudging their meaning or outcome. Yet the meaning attributed to an experience retrospectively cannot establish that it carried a developmental direction from the outset. We argue that clinical and research understanding requires attention to the experience of involvement, the psychological functions a behaviour comes to serve and the meanings attributed to it over time. An activity may sustain self-worth, regulate distress and enrich life while progressively narrowing the possibilities available beyond it. To investigate these changing configurations, we consider the limits of group-level findings for understanding individuals, alongside dynamical systems, fuzzy logic and longitudinal assessment. These approaches may illuminate how involvement becomes rigid, provided their clinical significance is theoretically grounded and continuous monitoring does not generate new forms of pathologisation. Ultimately, understanding extreme experiences requires us to examine how their intensity and subjective meaning become intertwined with the psychological functions of behaviour, shaping trajectories that may lead toward personal growth, persistent vulnerability, or increasingly restrictive patterns of involvement.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Nogueira-López et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: