Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Rain-on-grid models of small Mediterranean catchments require a loss model, usually the SCS Curve Number (SCS-CN) or the Green-Ampt (GA) methods, rarely tested inside two-dimensional solvers. This study compares the two methods as implemented in the same TUFLOW HPC model of the Aron stream (37.5 km², southern Italy), for the multi-pulse flood of 12–13 February 2026, under radar and rain-gauge forcing. Lacking discharge data, the comparison is evaluated on a sensitivity analysis of 24 runs varying the antecedent runoff condition (ARC) and the initial abstraction for SCS-CN, the initial water content, texture source, spin-up and saturated conductivity (Ks) for GA, and roughness. The SCS-CN peak varied 6- to 12-fold across ARC classes. Conversely, the GA peak varied by only 4% across initial water contents, since crest rainfall exceeded the GA capacity about tenfold, but decreased by 28–77% for a threefold to tenfold Ks, its dominant uncertainty. Despite producing similar overall volumes, the initial discharge peak reached only 2–8% of the main peak under ARC III and 35–44% with the GA spin-up. Additionally, GA reinfiltrated 12–18% of losses as run-on flow, a process absent in SCS-CN. Surface velocities confirmed only crest timing. Thus, a single SCS-CN simulation is not conservative for multi-pulse floods.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Penna et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: