Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Complementary navigation combines destination-directed robot guidance with physical user adjustments through an interaction handle. We compared it with white-cane navigation and autonomous robot guidance in 20 blindfolded sighted adults without prior experience using a white cane. Participants completed five trials per condition on an indoor course containing static and dynamic obstacles, a slope, and a bump. User engagement share (UES) measured the proportion of navigation time during which physical input changed the applied movement command. Completion rates were 99%, 86%, and 67% for complementary navigation, white-cane navigation, and autonomous robot guidance, respectively. Complementary navigation significantly exceeded autonomous guidance (p=0.005). Among successful trials, completion time was significantly shorter than with white-cane navigation but did not differ significantly from autonomous guidance. When unsuccessful trials were assigned 300 s, complementary navigation had significantly lower mean navigation time than both alternatives. Mean UES was 34.59%. NASA-TLX scores were significantly lower than with white-cane navigation across all dimensions, although effort was higher than with autonomous guidance. The white-cane comparison may underestimate trained cane users’ performance. Two blind participants completed all complementary navigation trials in an exploratory evaluation. These findings support complementary navigation under the tested conditions.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Lee et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: