Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
We prove a class-relative negative resolution of the canonical constructive Yang–Mills mass-gap formulation on ℝ⁴, together with an exact calibration of what such a result can and cannot deliver. Inside the declared canonical class C⁻(ℝ⁴) := {M : H1 ∧ H2⁻} (formalized in both conjunctive and literal disjunctive forms), the Osterwalder–Schrader / Wightman package and a strict spectral mass gap Δ > 0 are mutually exclusive, and the five-part non-vacuity and conjunct-separation certificate holds. We do not construct a Yang–Mills measure on ℝ⁴, we do not claim the Clay Millennium Prize, and we do not claim ¬Clay for the physical theory. Principal Results in Audited Edition v21: 1. Eight Named Class-Free Theorems and Five Class-Free Propositions (Independent of H1 and H2⁻):• Peano–Archimedes No-Gap & Reciprocal-Tail Expulsion: Any operator retaining the reciprocal infrared tail E(λ) = (λ + 1)⁻¹ has Δ = 0; conversely, any rational lower bound Δ = (p + 1)/(q + 1) > 0 expels the entire tail (q + 2 + k)⁻¹ for all k ∈ ℕ, and any positive rational lower bound (HasPositiveRationalGap) closes irrational spectral gaps such as Δ = √2 (witnessed by the Pell sequence E_n = p_n/q_n = 3/2, 17/12, 99/70, … ↓ √2).• Sharp Positivity Criterion for the Refined Gribov–Zwanziger (RGZ) Family: For D_RGZ(p²) = (p² + M²)/(p⁴ + (M² + m²)p² + λ⁴), reflection positivity holds iff ρ ≥ 0 ⇔ OS2 ⇔ W0 ⇔ M²m² ≥ λ⁴. Under the physical RGZ horizon parametrisation λ⁴ = M²m² + 2Ng²γ⁴, positivity forces γ = 0; every γ ≠ 0 violates reflection positivity, and no rational truncation is simultaneously reflection-positive and free of positive-metric asymptotic quanta.• Gauge-Invariant Topological Susceptibility (χ_t > 0): Contact terms supported at {0} contribute identically zero to OS2 on {x₄ ≥ ε > 0}; an explicit Gaussian white-noise family realizes OS2 ∧ W0 ∧ (Δ = m > 0) ∧ (χ_t > 0).• Operator Dimension & Beta-Sign Discriminator: A dimension-four composite :φ_m⁴: in a free gapped 4D scalar theory reproduces the |x|⁻⁸ singularity and a⁻⁴ quartic divergence while all OS/Wightman axioms and Δ = m > 0 hold. Criticality (d = 4, [g] = 0) is shared by φ⁴₄ and Yang–Mills, whereas the sign of β discriminates: φ⁴₄ triviality requires β > 0, while Yang–Mills has β < 0 (as noted in Jaffe–Witten 2000), and the 2D Gross–Neveu model ([g] = 0, β < 0) is a rigorous asymptotically free gapped theory. 2. The Logvinovich Dichotomy (D1–D5), Burden Calibration & Three Legitimate Positions:• Proving the completeness bridge (Bridge := ∀M, Clay(M) ⇒ M ∈ C⁻(ℝ⁴)) is logically equivalent to proving the absolute negative solution ¬∃M, Clay(M). In the audited ontology, both ¬Bridge (D4) and ∃M, Clay(M) (D5, witnessed by the truth-value surrogate UnconstrainedCompatibleModel) are machine-checked.• Three Legitimate Referee Positions: (A) accept the reduction inside C⁻(ℝ⁴); (B) produce a finite Exit Certificate, which solves Clay positively and refutes H1, H2⁻, and Bridge; or (C) reject a named premise (H1, H2⁻, or A7). Only demanding a positive witness inside the excluded class is a formal category error. 3. Audit of Eight Attempted Closures of the Upper Exit (Clay ⇒ C⁻(ℝ⁴)):• Three sign-inverted existence theorems: trace anomaly (generates Λ_RG and blocks the dilation proof of H1), topological susceptibility χ_t > 0 (carried by an OS2-invisible contact term), and Buchholz–Fredenhagen BF82 (assumes Δ > 0 and derives cone localisation).• Two counterexample refutations: |x|⁻⁸ / χ_t non-integrability (reproduced by :φ_m⁴: in free gapped 4D scalar theory; χ_tξ² diverges in gapped 2D O(3) and is finite in 4D SU(3)) and Z_N one-form symmetry vs. asymptotic freedom (spectral gap ≠ area law; bare g₀ → 0 is UV; Balaban and Tomboulis point toward confinement).• Three regulator-removal audits: φ⁴₄ triviality dichotomy (beta-sign error + third branch along a fixed RP lattice action), order of limits a → 0, L → ∞ (restates the open Clay problem), and the covariant Dirac probe D_A (category error: D_A is a background probe, not the field-theory Hamiltonian H; free massive Dirac field is a counterexample). 4. Conditional Inevitability Theorem, No Free Reformulation & Kernel Self-Audit (C1–C7):• Under the declared consensus hypothesis P (∃M, Clay(M)), ¬Bridge holds and no sound argument whatsoever can close the upper exit, upgrading the sign-inversion ledger from an observation to a conditional theorem.• Any predicate Φ equivalent to Clay is exactly as hard as Clay, and Osterwalder–Schrader reconstruction runs one-way from the Euclidean measure to the spatial-slice Hamiltonian H (attacking the 3D slice attacks the output, never easier than the input).• Full Lean 4 kernel self-audit documenting packaging defects C1–C7, disjunctive H2⁻ closure, and finite-rank Schur/Sonin comparison (Andrews–Connes–La Gatta 2026). Files Included in This Deposit:• Logvinovich_v21.pdf — Complete 44-page audited monograph (Audited Edition v21).• Logvinovich_v21.tex — Reproducible LaTeX source of the monograph.• RoundSquare_v21.lean — Constructive Lean 4 formalization (44 Sections, 187 #print axioms checks): Sections 1–34 CI-confirmed with 0 sorry and 0 custom axioms; Blocks A–B (§35–36) locally kernel-confirmed on Lean v4.36.0-rc2; Blocks C–J (§37–44) sorry-free candidate modules. GitHub Repository & CI Verification: https://github.com/Dr-Logvinovich/round-squareCompanion Compact-Manifold Preprint (YM_V5, M_tot = S⁴ × T³): https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22674891
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Victor Logvinovich (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: