Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Background Untrustworthy publications contaminate scientific literature directly through their publication and indirectly by being cited. Journals/Publishers often respond to integrity concerns about publications by publishing an editorial response (editorial notice, expression of concern (EoC) or retraction). We investigated whether the type of editorial response affected citation rates. Methods We obtained citations for an index set of 172 randomised controlled trials (RCTs) with integrity concerns (41 received editorial notices, 38 EoCs and 23 were retracted) and control RCTs published in the same journal and year as each index RCT. We calculated monthly citation rates up to 60 months before and after the editorial response and compared them by editorial response type, and to the natural citation decline rate in control RCTs. Results 172 index RCTs had 10,603 citations from 6,376 articles. 3,330 matched control trials were identified for 151/172 index RCTs (115,948 citations, 87,811 articles). In the index trials and controls, citations increased steadily, peaking 45–65 months post-publication, then declining. We did not find statistically significant differences in citation decline post-editorial response amongst index trials receiving a retraction, EoC, or notice. Citations were lower in controls than index trials, so analyses were restricted to 1598 highly cited (> 25) controls. The natural rate of decline for highly cited control trials was not statistically significantly different from the post-editorial response rate for all 3 index groups. Conclusion We did not find that the decline in citation rates after editorial response publication differed by type of editorial response or from the natural decline in control trials without editorial responses.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Studd et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: