Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Solar wind values monitored at the Sun–Earth L1 point have been used to estimate the Earth-arrival time of interplanetary (IP) shocks associated with coronal mass ejections (CMEs) and co-rotating interaction regions (CIRs). In standard estimates, including NASA/OMNI database, the radial propagation speed of the IP shock is assumed to be the same as the measured solar wind (proton) speed after the shock, although these speeds are known to be different in both the shock theory and CME observations. To diagnose the actual differences between these speeds, we statistically compared them using spacecraft data at L1. The propagation speed is obtained from the time-of-propagation between the IP shock passage at the L1 monitoring point and the geomagnetic sudden commencement (SC) at the Earth. As the L1 monitoring point, we use three locations: two are the spacecraft (SOHO and ACE) locations, and the other is the estimated IP shock passage point upstream of the Earth nearest to Y=Z=0 in Geocentric Solar Ecliptic (GSE) coordinate that is calculated from timings and locations of the IP shock passage at both spacecraft (we call the triangle method). In statistics, we limited to the IP shocks with a clear geomagnetic SC signature and with velocity profiles consistent between SOHO and ACE. During 1998–2022, 375 IP shocks satisfied such conditions. For the solar wind speed ( V SW ), the highest value during 15 min after the IP shock passage observed by the selected spacecraft (SOHO or ACE) was used. We found the following tendencies. (1) As expected from the shock theory, arrival time of the IP shock to the Earth (represented by the geomagnetic SC) is earlier than the predicted arrival time of the shocked solar wind by 0–8 min. (2) The speed difference between the shock propagation and V SW after the shock (highest value during 15 min) is about +7 % compared to SOHO observation and +10 % compared to ACE observation. (3) Tilt angle of the shock estimated by simple 1D shock model using velocity changes across the shock of ACE gives, although this method has large instrumental uncertainty, generally consistent values what is estimated by triangle method within the uncertainty.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Yamauchi et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: