Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Background Implementation outcomes vary widely across contexts, yet existing theories, models and frameworks (TMFs) flag context as important without specifying its causal structure. We argue that ecological psychology's Behavior Setting Theory (BST) can be applied as a pragmatic framework for surfacing the setting-level mechanisms by which a setting produces its regularized patterns of behavior across contexts. Methods We explore BST's explanatory and practical value by examining the transfer of a self-measured blood pressure (SMBP) monitoring intervention from the United Kingdom (UK) to rural Ghana, where SMBP monitors are less commonly available. We used a multistep approach to assess transfer potential. First, we mapped the UK at-home SMBP monitoring setting using the Behavior Setting Canvas (BSC), a tool designed to capture BST insights. We then compared this with the at-home SMBP monitoring setting in Ghana, where a field experiment was conducted. We analyzed differences in routines, role enactment, and setting-specific mechanisms affecting intervention functioning. We frame this study as an exploratory, qualitative comparative case study serving as a proof-of-concept demonstration of BST as an analytic and prescriptive lens, not as an empirical test or validation of BST's causal claims, nor as a measure of implementation or proof of the transferability of outcomes. Results Applying BST, we interpret synomorphy—alignment between a setting's elements and its overarching objective—as shaping SMBP monitoring within and across contexts, yielding both localized and generalizable learning. In the UK, SMBP monitoring is oriented toward real-time data sharing with clinicians, supported by infrastructure and props, user knowledge and skills, and maintenance mechanisms enforcing adherence. In Ghana, weaker synomorphy stemmed from resource gaps, limited capabilities, and distributed roles. Routines were less established, and maintenance mechanisms were nascent and inconsistent. We identified macro- and micro-level drivers of variation and insights for adaptation. Conclusions BST provides a new lens for understanding how interventions interact with setting-level mechanisms. It supports profiling settings as structured systems, informing context-sensitive adaptation, and advancing implementation science theory and practice. While promising, the approach is still being codified—it needs clearer guidance for identifying mechanisms and more support for informing design decisions. These are exciting frontiers for future work to strengthen BST's utility and impact.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Mariani et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: