Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
We develop and implement a two-step location–scale analysis for repeated physical measurements when the underlying distribution is not known. For a chosen substitute distribution, stationarity of population Kullback–Leibler information loss at fixed scale motivates the location score, which we apply to the observed measurements through empirical cross-entropy. Steiner’s curvature rule then defines a companion scale separately. We place Gaussian, Cauchy, and logistic substitutes in one common construction and implement them reproducibly on a physics benchmark. For the logistic substitute, we pair the established bounded location score with a scale defined by the curvature rule rather than by a fitted tuning constant or a scale-likelihood equation. For Gaussian measurements with different quoted uncertainties, an experiment-level curvature convention and a stated variance mapping give an exact algebraic connection to a standard residual-based variance estimate for a weighted fit. Applied to a published 21-measurement neutron-lifetime compilation, the inverse-variance weighted, most frequent value, and logistic locations are 878.689, 881.164, and 882.835 s, respectively. These values are benchmark results of the compared constructions and are not proposed as a new recommended neutron lifetime.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
V. V. Golovko (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: