Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This hypothesis-generating paper proposes a hybrid theoretical framework for music performance anxiety (MPA) that separates two questions often conflated in the literature: how severe MPA is, and why it occurs. The model treats MPA severity as dimensional while hypothesizing that comparable levels of severity may arise through different dominant causal and maintaining mechanisms. Five provisional profiles are proposed: skill-deficit, trait-anxious, social-evaluative, somatic-dominant, and trauma/shame-based. These profiles are not presented as established natural kinds or mutually exclusive diagnostic categories; rather, they are clinically and theory-derived, overlapping configurations intended to generate discriminating empirical predictions. I first distinguish physiological arousal from anxiety and performance impairment and review limitations in optimal-arousal, flow, positive/negative and facilitating/debilitating anxiety accounts of MPA. I then specify the causal architecture and core propositions of the hybrid model, propose a multimethod research assessment battery, and derive profile-specific predictions concerning developmental history, contextual reactivity, psychophysiology, and treatment response. Treatment matching is framed as a testable moderation hypothesis. Boundary conditions and comorbidity are specified operationally, and designs are proposed for testing whether mechanism-matched treatment outperforms severity-focused and standard treatment. The model predicts that mechanism-informed treatment selection will explain outcome variance beyond baseline MPA severity. Alternative dimensional, hierarchical, network, and continuous-profile accounts are considered, and a program of taxonometric, latent-profile, longitudinal, experimental, psychophysiological, and stratified intervention research is proposed. The framework is intended as a falsifiable research program for explaining heterogeneity in MPA and improving mechanism-informed intervention.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Dianna Theadora Kenny (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: