Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Instructors of introductory physics courses have increasingly adopted student-centered instruction, or “active learning,” over the past few decades. Active learning is generally considered more effective because knowledge construction and learning are socially situated, and active learning strategies emphasize student interaction. Extensive literature also shows that how students interact in an active learning class, as well as the class structure itself, may significantly affect learning and performance. We recently developed an instructional method based on deliberate practice in solving “real-world” physics problems—context-rich problems that often require students to seek out information and make their own simplifying assumptions. This method drastically changes the nature of the tasks students work on during class. We therefore sought to understand how students interacted in this environment and how those interactions might relate to learning and academic performance. Data were collected from three student groups during the Spring 2022 semester at a large research university. Using a three-dimensional framework to analyze group interactions, we found substantial variation in the groups’ cognitive, social, and affective behaviors. Results showed that each group had unique strengths and self-organization strategies. However, despite sometimes responding to the material with negative emotions, typically frustration, all three groups demonstrated psychological safety and social cohesion, even when cognitive work was distributed unevenly. Future work should examine how psychological safety develops amid mutual frustration during group problem-solving.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
DiQuattro et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: