Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Biodiversity in freshwaters is declining faster than in any other ecosystem. The ecological effects of small hydropower (SHP, <1 MW) on river connectivity and fish populations are established, while these installations contribute only marginally to electricity production. National policy responses nonetheless vary considerably. Finland has initiated a deliberate phase-out of SHP through dam-removal funding and an ongoing Water Act reform, whereas in Germany the regime was further entrenched: a 2022 attempt to restrict SHP subsidies failed, and the technology was instead included in an “overriding public interest” provision for renewables. This paper traces these contrasting outcomes to differences in public demand for technology phase-out, defined as the combination of issue salience and public opinion . Drawing on 31 expert interviews and policy documents, we ask how public demand arises and how its presence or absence shapes phase-out politics. We argue that where public demand forms, it can move decision-making from expert into public arenas, creating electoral incentives for reform and weakening incumbents’ influence. Where it remains absent, the issue stays in expert arenas, where incumbents tend to retain advantages to hold the status quo. We further propose cultural anchoring of a technology’s harms, their resonance with shared meanings, values and lived experience, as an important condition for public demand to form. For SHP, whose impacts fall on river ecosystems, we link this anchoring to experience-based relationships with the affected rivers. The study points to public demand as an important factor in overcoming regime lock-in and advancing deliberate phase-outs in sustainability transitions.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Widdel et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: