Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
It has been argued that organisms’ evolutionary responses might be accelerated when specific traits respond to selection without genetically or phenotypically correlated changes in other traits. This property–of greater covariances within sets of traits than between sets of traits–is described by the general concept of modularity. Modularity has been extensively studied at the phenotypic and quantitative genetic levels, but these approaches capture statistical associations between traits rather than identifying the genomic causes of their covariation. Here we define and discuss the importance of genomic modularity, which describes trait associations arising from the physical co-localisation of causative loci. This provides a framework for testing modularity as a hypothesis at the genomic level. We distinguish narrow-sense genomic modularity, in which trait covariance arises from the physical co-localisation of causal loci, from broad-sense genomic modularity, which additionally encompasses covariance generated by epistasis, trans-acting gene regulation, and selection. Focusing on narrow-sense modularity, we evaluate evidence for it across natural and laboratory systems. Restricted pleiotropy and discrete genomic architectures are common, but direct evidence for narrow-sense genomic modularity is limited. Consequently, the role that modular genomic architectures play in facilitating adaptation, speciation, and phenotypic diversification remains unclear. We present formalised approaches for measuring and testing narrow-sense genomic modularity across mapped traits and suggest that resolving the link between modularity and adaptation requires a robust hypothesis-testing framework and large-scale comparative tests of genomic modularity across diverse taxa.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Yusuf et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: