Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
BACKGROUND: Programmatic assessment has become the dominant paradigm in health professional education, yet postgraduate specialty training programmes have been slow to adopt it. Understanding tensions in programmatic assessment implementation may inform strategies to manage them and enable postgraduate training programmes to realise its potential. METHODS: Using scoping review methodology, three databases, PubMed (Ovid) Web of Science Core Collection and ERIC, were systematically searched to explore how postgraduate training programmes manage tensions in adopting programmatic assessment principles. Screening yielded 47 articles. Tensions and strategies to manage them were explored using qualitative content analysis. RESULTS: Multiple paradoxical tensions were identified. Learning tensions caused resistance to change from prior assessment experience. Organising tensions occurred system-wide, with conflict between need for structure versus flexibility. Performing tensions arose from differing stakeholder goals (patient safety versus trainee needs). Belonging tensions emerged in relationship conflicts, for example, when supervisors balance judging and supporting roles. Intersecting tensions included learning-performing tensions (appearing competent while learning) and performing-organising tensions (service provision vs. training time). Management strategies included both/and approaches: co-production and coaching reduced goal conflicts enabling a growth mindset; innovative implementation approaches balanced structure and flexibility; clarity of communication and shared mental models facilitated a 'paradox mindset' by openly acknowledging tensions. Either/or approaches, for example, separating assessor and coach roles, were also seen. DISCUSSION/CONCLUSION: Having a repertoire of strategies to manage paradoxical tensions in assessment including either/or and both/and approaches aligns with recent paradox literature. Making tensions explicit allows innovative not defensive responses. Open mindsets (organisational and individual) enable resilience and adaptability when it comes to change; fear of change can impede progress. Clarity and shared mental models enable effective communication despite persistent tensions. Future work could prospectively examine tensions during programmatic assessment implementation.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Murphy et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: