Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
, but previous studies have yielded a >10-fold difference in the estimated clearance rate for HIV-1 in humans compared to SIV in macaques. These prior analyses often employed insensitive assays, short observation periods, disparate methodologies, and the assumption of monophasic clearance kinetics, complicating interpretation of discordant findings. Here, we investigated virion clearance by intravenously infusing non-infectious SIV, HIV-1 wild-type (WT), and envelope-negative HIV-1 (Env-) into SIV-infected macaques exhibiting a range of baseline plasma viral loads. Using highly sensitive virologic assays, we monitored infused virion clearance over eight hours across ~6 logs of dynamic range. We show that virion clearance is universally multiphasic, with triphasic models providing the best fit. SIV and HIV-1 WT were cleared with indistinguishable kinetics, including a rapid first phase (mean half-life: ~2.5 min) during which >99% of infused virus was cleared. We also identified previously undetected second and third clearance phases with progressively slower kinetics, with mean half-lives of ~17 and ~126 min (when estimable), respectively, for both SIV and HIV-1 WT. HIV-1 Env- virions showed modestly but significantly slower first-phase clearance rates, suggesting a potential role for Env in early virion clearance. Baseline viral burden did not correlate with clearance kinetics, providing no evidence for a saturable clearance capacity. Our results indicate that clearance kinetics are largely independent of viral load and virus type, suggesting that prior discrepancies stem from methodological limitations, modeling assumptions, or species-specific differences between macaques and humans. IMPORTANCE: Accurate characterization of HIV-1 clearance from the blood is fundamental for understanding viral pathogenesis, infected-cell lifespans, and the dynamics of antiretroviral therapy-mediated suppression. Historically, distinct experimental systems suggested that HIV-1 clearance in humans is significantly slower than SIV clearance in macaques. This study resolves proposed explanations for this longstanding discrepancy by directly comparing the clearance of non-infectious SIV and HIV-1 particles from macaque blood using highly sensitive virologic assays. We demonstrate that both viruses are cleared at nearly identical rates, regardless of the total amount of virus circulating in each animal, and reveal for the first time that virion clearance is not a simple monophasic decay process but represents a complex, multiphasic process that alters how we understand viral biology. Our findings indicate that previous disparities were likely driven by technological limitations, monophasic modeling assumptions, and/or species-specific differences rather than virus-specific differences or a saturable virion clearance mechanism.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Köse et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: