Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This article explores and intervenes in epistemic contests about journalism’s commitment to objectivity by proposing a novel conceptualisation of objectivising knowledge practices. Using data from three focus group discussions in which young people in Slovakia responded to a controversial video report on the 2015 migration crisis, we use a ventriloquial approach to demonstrate how the objectivity of the report was not just evaluated but communicatively organised. Each group enacted what we propose to call a distinct regime of objectivisation, or delegated speaking. Importantly, in all three regimes, objectivity is achieved through subjectivities rather than against them, by decentring authority and perspective. Procedural objectivisation multiplies subjectivities by making several voices speak. Moral objectivisation orients subjectivity toward attachments deemed appropriate to the situation. Visual objectivisation mobilises the viewer’s subjectivity by letting audiences see for themselves and form their own judgment. Disagreements about the truth value of the news are thus not necessarily about whether it is objective in any absolute sense as much as whether its distribution of voices and evidential forces matches expectations of how journalism should make the world speak, what part audiences play in making it speak, and, more broadly, what kind of social role, power and responsibility the epistemic practice of journalism is accorded.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Smith et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: