Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Chronic insomnia disorder (CID), subthreshold depression (StD), major depressive disorder without suicidal ideation (MDD-NSI), and MDD with suicidal ideation (MDD-SI) are clinically related but phenotypically distinct. Whether brain abnormalities across these phenotypes show shared or distinct patterns at regional, circuit, and network levels remains unclear. In this cross-sectional study, we applied a multiscale framework to MRI data from 1,035 healthy controls and 241 clinical participants (CID, n = 77; StD, n = 46; MDD-NSI, n = 68; MDD-SI, n = 50) across four cohorts, with clinical participants recruited from two hospitals. At the regional level, individual morphometric similarity (MS) deviation maps across 1,000 cortical regions were derived using Bayesian normative modeling. At the circuit level, extreme regional deviations were mapped to functional circuits using a lesion network mapping–inspired approach based on resting-state functional connectivity from an independent cohort of 93 healthy participants. At the network level, deviations were mapped onto seven canonical functional networks. Overlap was quantified as the proportion of individuals showing regional deviations or corresponding circuit- and network-level involvement. Case–control differences were assessed using group-label permutation tests, while spatial permutation tests further evaluated whether circuit- and network-level convergence exceeded that expected from deviation burden and spatial organization. Extreme positive MS deviations were common across groups but showed minimal regional overlap (≤ 6%), indicating marked interindividual heterogeneity. Circuit-level overlap was substantially higher than regional overlap; case–control increases were limited in CID, widespread in StD, and more spatially restricted in MDD-NSI and MDD-SI. After accounting for deviation burden and spatial organization, only focal convergence near the precuneus remained in MDD-NSI and MDD-SI. At the network level, increased overlap was observed in StD, MDD-NSI, and MDD-SI, but only MDD-SI showed burden-independent convergence within the default mode network. Negative deviations showed similarly low regional overlap but weaker higher-order convergence. Brain abnormalities across the insomnia–depression spectrum are highly heterogeneous regionally, with a tendency toward greater convergence at higher levels of functional organization. These findings provide an exploratory group-level characterization of shared and distinct patterns of brain abnormalities across related clinical phenotypes.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Liu et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: