Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Martyn Rady has earned much acclaim for his monumental new history of Central Europe since Roman antiquity. This is fully justified. The Middle Kingdoms is an insightful, engaging, wonderful book that surprises even readers who have been studying the history of the region for decades.How does Rady manage to tell the story of such a large area that includes, in contrast to most other treatments of the subject, all German-speaking peoples and lands (not just Austria!) over the last two thousand years? For one thing, he is a master of focusing on one or two major topics to structure each of the thirty-four chapters that divide up that long story. Then, he has constructed a sophisticated narrative framework that allows him to connect most of the subjects he treats without losing oversight of all the many peoples, rulers, places, events, and developments he spreads throughout the book. At times, topics appear to be unrelated, and the reader feels she has lost her way, until they surprisingly reappear in a completely different context, leading back to the main road. Therefore, one absolutely needs to read all 515 pages!Rady starts by introducing the medieval figures of the “dogmen,” terrible monster-humans with dog-like heads who were believed to invade Central Europe from the East, spreading terror and despair. These impossible creatures reflected the fears and anxieties of people who had experienced the very real horrors of military invasions from Asia. The book ends with the last transfiguration of the “dogmen” in the form of the Russians invading Ukraine in 2022. This gives the book a gloomy outlook, which shows how much the tone in the historiography of Central and Eastern Europe has changed since the happy 1990s, when handbooks ended with the peaceful integration into the (formerly) Western European Union. Rady now presents both endings as possibilities for the future of this vulnerable civilization that lies both at the center and the border of the continent (9).He begins the story with the “unlucky” Roman poet Ovid, who complained bitterly about his exile at the unsecure border of the empire in Southeastern Europe. After the end of the Roman period, “Franks, Slavs, and Hungarians adopted a common cultural code of kingship, Catholic Christianity, law, knighthood and chivalry. But curiously, that code was also infused with remembrance of the Huns” (20). The first twelve chapters are dedicated to the medieval period of the fragile new civilization, where these Roman ideas were adopted and transformed into new kingdoms while the threats from the East continued. The Renaissance was threatened by the onslaught of the Ottoman Empire which, paradoxically, allowed the thriving of the Reformation—a new, world-changing religious movement born in Central Europe.In the next ten chapters (12–21), Rady tells the stories of various new ideas that radically changed the “Middle Kingdoms,” from the Renaissance at the court of King Matthias I of Hungary, Luther’s Reformation, and the ensuing civil wars and Ottoman challenges, to the ideas to create a strong, intervening, regulating state, like the “machine state” idea in Prussia (294). Is the culture of Central-Eastern Europe formed profoundly by state bureaucracies, as Rady states? In contrast, “Englishmen are supposed to have hardly noticed the state until the First World War, when they received their first tax demands and call-up papers. By then, Central Europeans had been living with it for two centuries or more” (258). This might be true, but it also sounds like a variation of the old “Sonderweg” theory, in which the Eastern part of the continent was simply lacking citizenship rights and freedoms compared to the “progressive” West.The following chapters deal with the long nineteenth century, between Napoleon’s reshuffling of the area; the arrival and spread of nationalism, until 1914, when the “war against Central Europe” (chapter 29, p. 414) began; followed by an escalation of violence until the 1980s. In the context of the “Mitteleuropa” debates (“a curious sematic shift,” 490) of the 1980s (embodied by the famous article by Milan Kundera1), Rady correctly points out that the idea had mostly to do with the attempt to distance Czechs, Hungarians, and Poles from Russia (492). How does Rady interpret 1989? “As with every great event, hollowness soon prevailed” (495), he writes, which also reflects the disappointment of Western liberals of today in light of the authoritarian backlash of the last decades.Sometimes Rady’s interpretations could have been more nuanced, for example when he highlights the lack of denazification of West Germany in the 1950s without mentioning the achievements of Konrad Adenauer, especially Westbindung [Western integration], democratization of institutions, and more (489). But the book is such a pleasure to read and gives so much food for thought that such minor flaws can be easily excused.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Árpád von Klimó (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: