Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Quantifying bottom-trawling effort is essential to assess its impacts on the seafloor, yet the two main vessel tracking systems—Vessel Monitoring System (VMS) and Automatic Identification System (AIS)—differ in spatial resolution, coverage, and reliability. Understanding their relative strengths and weaknesses is necessary to determine when each dataset is appropriate for seafloor impact assessments. To do so, we compared fishing effort as swept area ratio (SAR) of bottom trawlers operating in the Palamós and Blanes canyons (NW Mediterranean) using both VMS and AIS datasets. Results showed that VMS and AIS recorded comparable vessel activity in Palamós, whereas AIS severely underestimated fishing effort in Blanes, mainly because several vessels did not transmit AIS despite operating in areas with reliable AIS reception. Despite this data loss, AIS data provided higher spatial precision, accurately delineating fishing grounds and bathymetric features, while VMS tracks appeared more diffuse or geomorphologically implausible. The coarse temporal resolution of VMS also limited the identification of fishing activity in short fishing grounds. VMS remains an essential source for estimates of large-scale fishing effort where AIS is unreliable. In contrast, AIS should be prioritized in fleets with complete AIS transmission or in studies requiring high-resolution assessments of seafloor disturbance in complex environments such as submarine canyons.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Paradis et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: