Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
In high-choice media environments, people favor news sources that reinforce their issue attitudes or partisan identities, shaping polarized information diets. However, the interplay between issue attitudes and group-based partisan identities in driving selective news consumption remains underexplored. While research documents robust preferences for congenial content, few studies examine how initial news encounters – pro- versus counter-attitudinal – trigger psychological mechanisms that propel subsequent pro-attitudinal news selection, particularly when individuals’ policy attitudes align or conflict with their partisan affiliations (attitude–partisanship congruence). This study tests a parallel moderated mediation model in which initial news exposure moderates the impact of attitude–partisanship congruence on pro-attitudinal news selection through two competing mediators: cognitive dissonance and psychological reactance in South Korea’s polarized media landscape. Two survey experiments (N = 903) employed 2 (congruence: congruent vs. incongruent) × 2 (exposure: pro- vs. counter-attitudinal) between-subjects designs. Participants encountered news on contentious quota policies (regional, gender) before reporting dissonance/reactance and selecting headlines from balanced news sets. Cognitive dissonance showed less consistent patterns across the two studies, whereas counter-attitudinal exposure consistently elicited greater psychological reactance among congruent individuals. Parallel moderated mediation analyses revealed significant conditional indirect effects through psychological reactance, but not cognitive dissonance, under counter-attitudinal exposure across both studies. When attitudes align with partisan identities, psychological reactance emerges as the dominant mechanism sustaining defensive information choices, amplifying congenial news diets. These findings illuminate processes that reinforce partisan segregation and suggest that interventions targeting autonomy threats may disrupt biased exposure patterns more effectively than dissonance-based approaches.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Jung et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: