Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Large health systems frequently struggle to achieve consistent improvement in patient experience performance across diverse care settings. Uniform performance goals applied to departments with widely varying baseline performance can create misaligned expectations, leadership frustration, and limited sustained progress. In 2021, the Baptist Health Medical Group (BHMG) encountered these challenges across more than 300 primary care and medical specialty departments, with similar variability emerging in hospital-based departments. To address this, the authors developed the tiered performance structure (TPS), a stratified performance management model that aligns intervention intensity with both fiscal-year goal attainment and directional performance trajectory. TPS classifies each department into one of four tiers based on whether it is meeting its goal and whether or not performance is improving over time, pairing each tier with standardized expectations for leadership engagement and improvement planning. The TPS model was implemented within primary care and medical specialty BHMG departments in September 2021 and expanded systemwide in September 2023 across more than 800 departments to include ambulatory surgery, emergency, inpatient, outpatient services, and urgent care departments. Among more than 300 primary care and medical specialty departments, the collective Average Service Rank (ASR) - a composite measure representing the average national percentile rank across patient experience survey domains - increased from 46 (range 1-99) prior to implementation in 2021 (year 1) to 91 by March 2026 (year 5). Systemwide improvements in ASR were observed across all major care settings, including an 8-point increase in Hospital Consumer Assessment of Healthcare Providers and Systems (HCAHPS) (from 51 to 59), a 23-point increase in ED surveys (from 41 to 64), an 8-point increase in Outpatient and Ambulatory Surgery Consumer Assessment of Healthcare Providers and Systems (OAS CAHPS) (from 51 to 59), and a 31-point increase in Outpatient Services (from 54 to 85). This case study describes the development and implementation of TPS, the operational challenges encountered, and the lessons learned in creating a scalable, structured approach to patient experience improvement.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Ackerman et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: