Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Accurate sex identification is essential for animal research, veterinary practice, husbandry and conservation programs, yet it remains challenging in many amphibians because external sexual dimorphism is often weak or absent before sexual maturity. Ultrasonography has been proposed as a non-invasive alternative to more invasive procedures, but its utility for sex identification in juvenile frogs remains untested. This study evaluated the feasibility and reliability of high-frequency ultrasonography (HF-US) for gonadal sex identification in immature agile frogs ( Rana dalmatina ). A total of 101 HF-US examinations were performed on captive-reared froglets, originating from eggs collected from wild populations, with a body length of 4–5 cm. Sex assignments were validated using coelioscopy and genotypic sexing. HF-US produced an ambiguous result in 23% of examinations related to problems such as intestinal gas or ingesta. Among examinations where an unambiguous sex was assigned, overall accuracy was 56.4%, being higher in females (65.4%) than in males (38.5%). Ultrasonographic examinations were substantially faster (ca. 2 min on average) than coelioscopic procedures (ca. 30 min on average). Complications occurred only after coelioscopy, including postoperative wound dehiscence in six individuals and two deaths, mostly within one month after the procedure, during the two autumn months preceding winter hibernation. However, in one female, the healed incision reopened four months later during oviposition in the following spring. Altogether, HF-US provides an accessible, rapid and non-invasive approach for gonad examination; however, its high error rate in identifying immature gonads, particularly testes, is insufficient for reliable phenotypic sex identification in juvenile agile frogs. Coelioscopy provides substantially greater diagnostic certainty, but this advantage must be weighed against its non-zero invasiveness and associated animal-welfare risks. Therefore, we recommend further testing of HF-US, especially when validated non-invasive alternatives are not available, to explore if training with the species and age classes in question could ensure reliable sex identification by this method.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Balogh et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: