Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Unshell failed, but the June 2026 proposal for a recast of the Directive on Administrative Cooperation would move the EU debate on shell entities into the regime of mandatory disclosure: under the proposed Article 52, the substance criteria of DAC6 Hallmark D2 limbs (a) and (b) would be specified in a Council implementing act. This article asks what that act may legitimately contain, using the founder-managed company formed under Estonia’s e-Residency programme as a stress test: physically thin, yet with an identifiable natural person as beneficial owner. The pattern shows why the indicators based on physical substance inherited from Unshell are unreliable evidence of abuse; and primary law, including Article 291(2) TFEU and the ‘essential elements’ doctrine, would preclude the act from converting D2 into a general low-substance reporting trigger. The article therefore proposes a functional framework: preserve D2’s cumulative structure; state expressly that remote incorporation, outsourcing and lack of local premises or staff are not enough; assess substance by reference to real activity, control and fiscal risk; and protect transparent digital businesses through clear safe harbours tied to active income and identifiable beneficial ownership.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Semen Feldman (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: