Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Debates about AI-driven persuasion concentrate on content: falsehoods believed, opinions shifted, voters manipulated. This paper argues that a more consequential threat operates on the conditions under which a claim is taken up for evaluation at all. Generative AI enables protocol mimicry : the industrial-scale production of artifacts that satisfy the formal admission criteria of epistemic exchange (register, structure, citation, provenance markers) while decoupled from the epistemic labour those criteria evolved to indicate. Extending Floridi’s dyadic account of hypersuasion into a parameterised systemic model ( n persuasion events per evaluative period, verification time τ , bounded evaluative capacity C ) and drawing on a structural homology with denial-of-service attacks, the paper traces the degradation of democratic deliberation from engagement through overload to epistemic exhaustion : a stable behavioural equilibrium in which citizens retain the capacity to distinguish true from false but rationally abandon the effort to exercise it. Democracy is distinctively vulnerable at the level of legitimacy. A server that refused all formally valid connections would cease to provide its service; a democracy that systematically foreclosed plausible contestation would abandon a constitutive source of its legitimacy. Countermeasures sort by the layer on which they intervene. Where fact-checking, labelling, and media literacy add evaluative demands without producing compensating closure, they can accelerate the condition they treat, and the content-neutral proxy defence available to servers has no coherent democratic analogue. The question for democratic theory is whether a system whose legitimacy derives from epistemic engagement can survive conditions that render such engagement irrational.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Marcel Cotta (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: