Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Production constitutes a fundamental concept for describing the power of modern societies to shape and distinguish themselves from their environment. However, beyond being merely descriptive, the concept also orders reality. Continuing the challenge posed to social theory by Jean Baudrillard while also taking seriously Michel Callon’s account of the performativity of economic concepts, I attempt a historical defamiliarization and a critique of the production concept. As the production concept helps structure reality so that creationary acts are distinguished from and foregrounded over destructive ones, it is fundamentally ill-suited as an analytical tool for grasping environmental destruction. I argue that, beginning in the seventeenth century, production’s meaning shifted from one rooted in natural, emanative processes to one centered on the creationary capacity of the productive human mind. This modern emphasis has made it possible to relegate environmentally destructive consequences of production to the status of mere side-effects – a limitation that, I show, recurs across metabolic rift theory, world-ecology, and ecologically unequal exchange theory. Thus, attempts to grasp the scale, persistence, and irreversibility of environmental destruction through the concept of production are hindered by the problematic logic embedded in the concept itself.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Maximilian Pieper (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: