Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
A HXD1C locomotive traction fan motor with excessive vibration under rated speed is diagnosed from front-and rear-end return-test records against dismantling-verified findings: the front-end bearing showed grease leakage, carbonization and stiff rotation (wear), while the rear-end outer ring suffered severe creep (fretting) corrosion yet rotated freely. Because segment gains were inconsistent, a data-integrity audit was performed first; time-domain indices, shaft-frequencynormalized spectra and resonant envelope spectra were then computed only on clean, unclipped segments and compared with theoretical 6310 frequencies. High-gain segments showed positive-direction clipping near full scale, inflating the apparent rear-end kurtosis to 38-67; after excluding them, clean-segment kurtosis dropped to 3.0-3.8, showing the apparent impulsiveness to be an acquisition artifact. Front-end clean segments were energetic and rich in low-order shaft harmonics, matching distributed lubrication/wear damage, whereas rear-end clean segments were flat broadband random vibration with no shaft-harmonic or bearing pass-frequency chain. The 6310 outer-race, inner-race and rolling-element frequencies lie within 0.9-1.6 Hz of the 3rd, 5th and 2nd shaft harmonics-indistinguishable at 1 s/1 Hz resolution-and, combined with non-impulsive creep, make the rear-end damage easily missed by conventional envelope analysis. The case exposes two field pitfalls (range-limited kurtosis artifacts; faultfrequency/shaft-harmonic coincidence) and motivates range headroom, clipping quality gates, longer records with a keyphasor or tacholess order tracking. Conclusions are limited to a single unit under one operating condition.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Luo et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: