Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Controllers for processes with fractional-order delay are usually tuned and evaluated with Padé and Oustaloup approximations. For integrating processes with the delay exp(−√s), this paper makes two contributions. It proposes a fractional lead-filtered FOPD (FLF-FOPD) controller, whose two lead elements provide a phase lead that grows like the process lag, and evaluates it and competing controllers on the exact process, revealing two pitfalls of the usual simulation chain. The Padé approximant fails above a closed-form frequency limit; the loop gain beyond it is small for 27 of 28 examined designs, but for the original FLF-FOPD tuning the phase margin was computed as 13.6° instead of 66.7°. The refined Oustaloup filter in FOMCON has a mid-band gain error (d/b)r that shortens the simulated delay by about 10% and made eight reproducible ITAE values from one study 8–22% too optimistic. In a benchmark with Ms ≤ 1.4, a bounded noise-to-control gain Mu and a 20 s horizon, the FLF-FOPD reduces to an FOPD for Mu ≤ 50. At Mu ≈ 860, the best of 60 runs lowers ITAE by a factor of 2.5 relative to the FOPD limit, at the cost of 3.5 times more control-signal noise, instability for α ≥ 0.7 and no benefit under saturation.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Yanmaz et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: